Build a verifiable bibliography
Connect the question, document versions, identifiers and inclusion criteria without confusing discovery with reading.
Prepare the task
A useful bibliography lets a reader locate each work and understand its relevance. It should also identify documents you could not examine.
- Question and main concepts
- Period, language or population criteria
- Tracking table without invented references
Follow the method
- 1Define scope
Record concepts, synonyms and inclusion criteria before selecting works. Search for findings contrary to your hypothesis as well.
- 2Compare references
Record title, authors, date, identifier and version. A record, preprint and published article can represent different states.
- 3Connect reading and citation
State what part was consulted and which point it supports. Mark inaccessible text instead of claiming its method was checked.
Two records look identical but the files differ: compare dates and versions before removing a supposed duplicate.
Choose the resource for the missing evidence
The directory records identify publishers and link to their official services. Choose by task; inclusion does not guarantee an outcome.
| Task | Resource | Check |
|---|---|---|
| Compare a reference and DOI | Crossref | Check authors, title and associated object. |
| Explore open journals | Directory of Open Access Journals | Check the particular journal and article. |
| Find a deposited version | HAL | Read the record and identify the available version. |
Keep a useful record
Use these fields in your own notes. This page does not collect your documents or personal details.
- Reference and identifier
- Version and access actually consulted
- Inclusion or exclusion reason
- Relevant finding and limits
UTF-8 CSV, semicolon-separated columns. No sign-up.
A synthesis based only on abstracts must disclose that limit; some decisions need a fuller examination.
Common questions
Does a DOI prove study quality?
It helps identify and locate an object; methods and content still need appraisal.
Should I retain excluded works?
A list with reasons makes the selection easier to assess.